Two Sister’s Diner
Theresa, New York, USA
Discover Two Sister’s Diner in Theresa, NY. Enjoy breakfast, lunch & dinner with fast service, local specialties, great coffee, and family-friendly dining.
38218 NY-37, Theresa, NY 13691, United States
Two Sister’s Diner
Theresa, New York, USA
Overview
Two Sister’s Diner is a cozy and casual diner located in Theresa, NY, offering a warm spot to enjoy comforting, home-style meals. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly service, this local favorite is praised for its fast service, great coffee, and delicious homemade desserts. The menu focuses on comfort food with healthy options, quick bites, and small plates perfect for any time of day.
Situated at 38218 NY-37, Two Sister’s Diner serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with quality table service and a variety of seating including booths and counters. Popular dishes range from hearty mushroom omelettes and bacon cheeseburgers to local specialties and weekly dinner specials like slow-roasted prime rib. Wheelchair accessible throughout, the diner also accommodates families with a kids’ menu and high chairs available.
Gallery
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Local favorites
Visitors appreciate this cozy diner for its welcoming atmosphere, tasty local dishes, and dependable service options that suit all dining preferences.
Many guests praise the efficient service that gets meals to the table quickly, ideal for those on a short break.
Known for its excellent coffee and tempting desserts like apple and mincemeat pie, this spot satisfies sweet cravings.
Enjoy classic comfort foods made with a local touch, from hearty mushroom omelettes to bacon cheese burgers with onion rings.
Families benefit from a kids' menu, high chairs, and accessible facilities including wheelchair-friendly seating and restrooms.
Convenient choices to either relax on-site in a casual setting or grab a quick, delicious meal to go.
With a 4.6 rating from over 400 reviews, the diner delivers satisfying meals and friendly service consistently.
Experience
Whether stopping by for a quick breakfast or settling in for a leisurely dinner, Two Sister’s Diner delivers a satisfying dining experience in a relaxed setting.
Whether craving a hearty mushroom omelette, a perfectly cooked bacon cheeseburger, or a slice of fresh apple pie, visitors can enjoy generous portions crafted with care. The diner welcomes groups and tourists alike, offering a range of seating options and attentive table service for a comfortable meal. — FoodPlacee editorial note
Start the day with comforting classics like the fried egg sandwich, Spanish omelette, or house muffins paired with excellent coffee in a cozy, quiet atmosphere.
Enjoy a family outing with kids’ menu options and high chairs available. The friendly staff and casual vibe make it easy to relax with little ones.
For those on the go, Two Sister’s Diner offers efficient takeout service featuring comfort food favorites ready to enjoy anywhere.
Plan a visit on Saturday evening to indulge in the slow-roasted prime rib special, a highlight of the weekly dinner offerings.
This inviting diner suits solo visitors seeking a friendly spot with fast service and quality meal options from breakfast through dinner.
Guest sentiment
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
"Great little spot for breakfast, lunch or dinner! Tons of home-made food. Special for the day was chicken and biscuits (huge portion). I had a patty melt and beer battered onion rings my husband haddock with in house made tarter sauce and fries. We took home some fantastic cinnamon doughnuts!"
"We just had breakfast and received sticker shock on the new pricing. This has been our favorite breakfast stop for years. We often went 2 or 3 times a week when in area. The only thing that comes with your eggs is toast. Anything extra costs extra. Home fries $4 25. Coffee $1.99 etc. We will not be back any time soon. As seniors in our 80+ years we do not have raises and need to watch spending. Good luck. We returned for another of their great breakfasts but adjusted our choices to accommodate our budget. Worked well."
"You have to check this place out! This family-friendly diner is ideal for breakfast and lunch. We visited for lunch this time and loved the variety of seating options, including tables, booths, and food bar stools. Two Sisters offers daily specials and a tasty menu. We tried the Bacon Cheeseburger Special, complete with toppings, crispy fries, and coleslaw. The burger was a juicy third-pound, cooked to order with a nice crispy edge and just the right amount of fat. While the bun was a bit large and did not taste toasted, it came with a side of mayo for customizing. We ordered ours medium well, but they accommodate different preferences. Each bite of the fresh, crisp lettuce added to the experience. To prevent the bun from falling apart, I recommend cutting the burger in half. The bacon was satisfyingly crispy, and the fries had a subtle breaded flavor, making them a great complement to the beef gravy. The portions are generous, so come hungry! The coleslaw was finely chopped with julienned carrots and just the right amount of dressing, leaving us wanting more after finishing our side. Our server, Sue, was friendly and attentive, ensuring everything was to our liking. The only downside was a pesky fly in the environment. The pie slices looked tempting, and I couldn’t resist ordering a raspberry cookie to go, which was a perfect ending to the meal. We definitely plan to return for more—especially for pie! #baconcheeseburger #cheeseburger #fries #coleslaw #frsshicedtea #gravy #twosistersdiner #ny #nyfoodie #flooogoltravelreviews"
"Killer liver and onions! It's been cold out, stopped in needed a hearty hot meal and to warm up. Liver was damn good seared and still moist ! Sweet toasty onions were topped with 4 crispy strips of bacon. Bowl of taters and brown gravy. Yup I need a nap now. Thank you guys! Husband loved his bacon cheese burger and the chocolate chip cookies too."
"Staying in Alex Bay and decided to try a diner away from there. Glad we did, a nice looking and clean place. I had a sausage and cheese omelet and home fries. Food was good and the prices were reasonable. Would definitely go again when in the area."
"It's a bit pricey for a burger but it IS a real burger cooked the way you want it. (And they get that right!) The order of fries is a bit small but I did get gravy & cheese on them. But still.....pricey. Very nice people."
"Stopped in on our way home from Alexandria Bay and had a great breakfast, I had the ham and cheese omelette which was chucked full of ham and cheese, along with a side of hash, I couldn't eat it all, my wife had chipped beef over toast and enjoyed it because its something we don't see often, would definitely recommend two sisters diner, and will return"
"Wheeled in here for breakfast after a long morning. I drove past this place a few times, his father was a spot where I can park my semi the other day, so it all kinda worked out. There was a gang of locals in there, and I've learned that if there is a large group of older, very familiar acting locals the food is about to be really good. I was not disappointed. My breakfast was served hot and fresh, with the home fries being cooked absolutely perfectly. The woman who was serving the place really seems to know her stuff. From where I was seated I had a clear view into the kitchen, and everything was clean and well-organized. I will definitely be coming back."
Visit info
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 07:00 AM - 02:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM |
| Thursday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM |
| Friday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM |
| Saturday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM |
| Sunday | 07:00 AM - 02:00 PM |
This diner welcomes guests mostly from early morning to evening, making it perfect for breakfast, lunch, or an early dinner.
On the map
Find your way to Two Sister’s Diner in New York .
Questions answered
Find answers to common questions about Two Sister’s Diner, from menu options to parking and accessibility.
For owners
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.